Paid Search Case Study: One Campaign’s Conversion Cost Down 96%

One nonbrand search campaign for a prenatal supplement brand saw its cost per conversion fall 96% from May to June 2026, from a base of one conversion.
A clean desk with a keyboard, a mouse and a phone, ready for a paid search review.

Quick answer: One nonbrand search campaign for a prenatal supplement brand went from a $570.96 cost per conversion on 1.00 conversion in May 2026 to $25.48 on 6.04 conversions in June, a 96% drop as the June report states. That is one campaign, not the account. The May base was one conversion, and spend on the campaign fell 73% in the same month, so read this as an early signal, not a final score. This case study covers May to July 2026 only.

We wrote this Google Ads case study for wellness and supplement brands that buy paid search. Every figure comes from the client’s monthly reports for May, June and July 2026, and we name the report beside each one. June figures come from the Paid Media Performance Report for June.

What was the starting point for this paid search account?

The May report showed brand search working well and one nonbrand search campaign barely converting.

In May 2026, brand search was the most efficient campaign in the account, at $4.89 per conversion. The nonbrand search prospecting campaign cost $570.96 and produced one conversion. The May report also flagged 46 of 48 Performance Max asset groups as poor or not eligible, and 83% of paid clicks landing on the homepage. It noted that brand and prospecting campaigns should be judged separately, because brand will always run a lower cost per conversion.

What did we change in the account?

The May report set June priorities for the whole account, and the July review lists what moved in July.

June. The May report set priorities across the account, not only for the nonbrand campaign. They included pausing this campaign and plans to optimize nonbrand search targeting and ad copy, optimize Performance Max prospecting, test a product page against the homepage, and archive the poor asset groups. The June report is a results dashboard and does not list which changes were made, so we cannot tie this one campaign’s June result to a single change.

July. The July review credits pausing underperforming pre and postnatal keywords and products for the Google conversion rate gain. It credits the upper funnel shift on Meta for the higher reach. It lists a dedicated creative production line, continued upper funnel work and archiving legacy asset groups as in motion.

What were the results from May to July 2026?

The nonbrand campaign’s cost per conversion fell 96% on a base of one conversion, the wider Google account improved, and Meta cost per purchase rose in June before it fell in July.

The table names the report for each figure. Where we show a June value beside a July value, the June value comes from the June report and the July value comes from the July review.

MetricBeforeAfterPeriod and source
One nonbrand search campaign, cost per conversion$570.96 on 1.00 conversion$25.48 on 6.04 conversions (down 96%)May to June 2026, May and June reports
Same campaign, cost$570.96$153.94 (down 73%)May to June 2026, May and June reports
Google Ads, whole account, cost per conversion$24.87$21.14 (down 14%, as the June report states)May to June 2026, May and June reports
Performance Max prospecting campaign, cost per conversion$81.66$49.11 (down 38%, as the June report states)May to June 2026, May and June reports
Performance Max prospecting campaign, conversions20.4861.86May to June 2026, May and June reports
Meta spend$7,215.08$12,998.26 (up 80%)May to June 2026, May and June reports
Meta cost per purchase$54.25$66.66 (up 23%)May to June 2026, May and June reports
Meta click through rate1.79%1.15% (down 36%)May to June 2026, May and June reports
Meta cost per purchase$66.66$55.14 (down 17%)June to July 2026, June report and July review
Meta impressions1.07 million3.45 million (up 221%)June to July 2026, June report and July review
Google cost per conversion$21.14$18.17June to July 2026, June report and July review
ROAS (June report) vs blended ROAS (July review)1.752.17June to July 2026, June report and July review
Total spend$18,481.04$14,899.37 (down 19%)June to July 2026, June report and July review

The campaign’s drop was not isolated. In the same June report, cost per conversion across the Google Ads account fell 14% and the Performance Max prospecting campaign’s fell 38%, while Meta cost per purchase rose 23% as Meta spend rose 80%. The campaign’s own spend fell 73%, so its lower cost per conversion came with far less spend. The May report’s June action list included pausing this campaign, while its opportunities section said to optimize it instead. The reports do not confirm which happened.

The July review states changes against a June base that does not match the June report’s June values, so for Google cost per conversion and ROAS we show both values and state no change.

What do these numbers not show?

The May base was one conversion, so a 96% drop from it is a small sample, not proof of a lasting rate, and the campaign’s spend also fell 73%. Figures come from three monthly reports that define some measures separately, so we name the report beside each one. The window is three months, and July spend was 19% lower than June, so we cannot say how these results hold at higher budgets.

What can a supplement brand take from this?

Three habits travel well to any paid search program for supplement brands.

  1. Read brand and nonbrand search apart. In May, brand search cost $4.89 per conversion and one nonbrand campaign cost $570.96. An average of the two hides both.
  2. Put the base next to every percentage. A 96% drop sounds large. It started from one conversion, and the campaign’s spend fell 73% in the same month.
  3. Read efficiency with spend. When Meta spend rose 80% in June, cost per purchase rose 23% and click through rate fell 36%. Check cost figures every month as spend changes.

If you want a paid media agency for supplement brands that works this way, see our paid social media advertising service. For another category, read our Hiya case study.

FAQ

What should a supplement brand check first in Google Ads?

Split brand and nonbrand search into separate reports before you change anything. Then check where paid clicks land and how many asset groups are flagged as poor. In this account the May report showed brand search at $4.89 per conversion, one nonbrand campaign at $570.96, 83% of paid clicks on the homepage and 46 of 48 asset groups flagged.

Why did the nonbrand campaign’s cost per conversion fall?

We cannot name one cause. The reports do not isolate changes made on this campaign. They show its spend fell 73% and its conversions rose from 1.00 to 6.04, from a May base of one conversion. Across the Google Ads account, cost per conversion also fell 14% in June, so the improvement was not limited to this campaign.

How did the rest of the account move?

In June, cost per conversion across Google Ads was $21.14, down 14%, and Performance Max prospecting fell 38% to $49.11, as the June report states. Meta moved the other way: spend rose 80% and cost per purchase rose 23% to $66.66. In July, the July review shows Meta cost per purchase down 17% to $55.14.

What should you ask a paid media agency to show you?

Ask for brand and nonbrand results shown separately, the number of conversions behind every cost figure, and the dates for each result. Ask which report each number comes from. An agency that hides the base or the dates is hiding the story.

Ashley Rector is Founder and CEO of Quimby Digital, a social media and paid media agency for parenting, women’s health, CPG and consumer brands.

Need a digital strategy that builds brand authority and drives measurable growth?